• Products
  • Projects
  • Stories
Stories

9 Trends in Trash: Smart Tech, Public Shaming & More

Local communities are employing innovative techniques, from high-tech trash bins to low-tech stickers and peer pressure, to clean up their waste management systems.

Waste Management
LO

London, ON

Canada

HB

Hobsons Bay, VIC

Australia

CN

Cumberland, NSW

Australia

BC

Breckland Council, GB

United Kingdom

gallery media 1
Highlights
  • IoT technology is being adopted around the world to help cities manage their waste bins.

  • Recycling is getting more refined, with local governments exploring how to recycle items and materials that don’t fit into standard programs.

  • Not every solution needs to be high-tech. Tactics such as stickers and report cards have been successful at changing citizen behavior.

  • Most communities are piloting programs in a specific neighborhood or geographic area before rolling it out city-wide.

Summary

While important, recycling is old news. Having a standard recycling program is table stakes for most local governments these days. But that doesn’t mean the waste management field is stale — far from it. Where the innovation is happening is in how recycling is being done, and other initiatives to enhance communities’ waste management systems.
These efforts run the gamut from technology-driven solutions, like mobile apps and smart bins, to old-school report cards and games with prizes. In one case, the city even created a public sh** list broadcasting dumping violators. Sometimes the same approach is being trialed on different sides of the world. Other times, cities are trying similar tactics — but having very different outcomes.
We’ve sorted through waste management projects from around the world and identified 9 trending or outside-the-box approaches to keeping things clean.
Let’s dumpster-dive in for some trash talk.

Smart bins make disposal more efficient

One common initiative around the globe is the adoption of “smart bins” for trash and recycling. These rely on sensors to respond to the amount of waste in a bin, and provide valuable data to the city about waste volume and service needs.
Cities experimenting with smart bins include Stonnington, VIC, which is using solar power to compact waste in smart bins once it reaches a certain volume. When the bins can’t compact any more and need to be serviced, they send a message to city workers, creating a more efficient, need-based waste management service. The city installed these bins in high-traffic areas as part of a pilot, and will use the learnings to inform future recycling initiatives. Similar efforts are underway in Darlington Borough Council, GB and Tea Tree Gully, SA (where bins were colorfully decorated to make them more eye-catching for passersby).
These smart compactor bins reduce the physical volume of waste — compressing the trash allows the bins to hold seven to eight times the amount of waste in a normal bin.
Not all smart bins compact the waste. In San Francisco, as part of the city’s overall efforts to reduce waste, sensors are being used in trash cans to monitor when they reach capacity. The effort, done in partnership with startup Nordsense, reduced the number of overflowing cans by 80%, and reduced the number of street cleaning requests in the city by 66%.
Overall, smart bins create significant efficiencies for city sanitation departments, who are notified when a bin is full or needs service. Workers now spend less time checking on or dumping half-full bins, and can spend that time on other maintenance work.

Underground garbage is a toss up

Rather than using bins and dumpsters on the street, some communities are storing their trash underground. These efforts have had mixed results. In Kissimmee, FL, a municipal effort to add trash containers beneath the street recently expanded to residential neighborhoods, too. The canisters have street-level hatches but all waste is stored out of sight. When it’s time to collect the waste, sanitation workers use trucks designed to lift and empty the containers. The program began in 2017 through a partnership with Underground Refuse Systems; now its expansion into residential communities marks the first time the containers are being used in a multi-family community in North America.
Raleigh, NC piloted a similar approach in 2019, using large underground containers from Molok to store trash and recycling. The program was intended to eliminate the carts and dumpsters that caused odors and blocked walkways, however about two months after its introduction, the city scrapped the initiative. While city officials credited the program with adding efficiencies from a waste management perspective, the response among local business owners and residents wasn’t supportive, as there were concerns about vermin, smell, and public health. The city may relocate the containers elsewhere but hasn’t solidified plans.
One city’s success doesn’t always translate to another. By piloting initiatives, getting community input, and rolling out projects strategically rather than all at once, cities can test into an approach that works best for their local needs.

Tackling single-use recycling

Many materials and items, such as single-use plastics, aren’t easily recycled under standard programs. The city of London, ON, is addressing this problem through Canada’s first single-use recyclable pilot. The city partnered with Reynolds Consumer Products to roll out the Hefty EnergyBag Pilot. Participating households disposed of items like plastic straws, take-out containers, plastic wrap, and more into special orange bags. The city would then work with businesses to turn the discarded plastics into natural gas, flooring, and patio furniture.
London’s pilot is still going, with more than 13,000 households participating. So far, city officials say, the community has been supportive. Regardless of the final outcome, London is leading the way in exploring innovative approaches to reduce plastic and landfills, and other local governments can follow the city’s lead.

Mobile apps make citizens more accountable

A number of localities have ambitious waste reduction and recycling goals. But these only work if citizens know how to participate correctly. A handful of cities, towns, and counties have introduced mobile apps to engage with and educate residents on local recycling programs.
One big point of confusion for many residents is which products can be recycled — and what bin each item belongs in. To address this, Hobsons Bay, VIC, introduced the Recycling 2.0 app. Residents can type a household object and the app will tell them which of the four available bins it belongs in. It’ll also inform them what waste pickup schedule they should follow, based on their home address. Norfolk County, ON, rolled out a similar app, which also allows the county to communicate any service changes with residents. The county notes that using the app (which is free to download and didn’t cost taxpayers any money to develop) saves advertising money, because it allows county officials to communicate directly with residents instead.
Sometimes, regularly scheduled pick-ups won’t cut it. For these instances, Cumberland, NSW partnered with OneBlink to develop a waste collection request app. In its first two years, the app handled 100,000 collection requests — plus it allows residents to report illegal dumping in their neighborhoods.
By putting waste management info into a format residents are used to, like a mobile app, local governments are setting their systems up for better participation, which makes them more efficient and more effective overall.

Recycling gets gamified

Apps aren’t the only tool local governments are using to get their citizens to recycle correctly. Around Vancouver, BC, communities are gamifying the practice. West Vancouver and North Vancouver partnered with ReCollect, a recycling technology company, to introduce Waste Evaders (in West Vancouver) and CitySort (in North Vancouver). The games ask players to identify which bin various objects belong in — from frozen food containers to device cables. After each level, the player gets to design features within a digital city.
No one said waste can’t be fun. These games take community engagement a step farther by making the concept of recycling enjoyable, and incentivising residents to participate.

A low-tech solution with big impact

Not every waste management solution needs to be technology-driven. In Regina, SK, stickers do the trick! The city’s CartSmart pilot inspected 2,000 households’ recycling bins and added an “Oops” sticker if items were incorrectly placed in the cart. If everything looked good, the recyclers received a “Good job” sticker. The 2,000 households started off at a 72 percent “Oops” rate, but upon the next round of inspections, 36% of carts had improved.
Phoenix, AZ, launched a similar pilot, but instead of stickers they used report card tags. After six weeks, the 1,200 participating households went from 70% “Oops” status to 70% getting a successful “Shine On!” nod. Report cards were also the tool of choice in Richmond, BC, where city workers would conduct random visual inspections of residents’ recycling bins. Those who passed the inspection received free passes to local recreation facilities.
The results of these programs show that sometimes the simple solution is the strongest one.

Public shaming gets the job done

Baltimore, MD knows that sometimes, all it takes is a little peer pressure to change behavior. As part of Mayor Bernard C. Young’s “Clean It Up” campaign, the city revealed ten worst offenders when it came to illegal dumping and trash violations. The information is posted and updated publicly on Baltimore’s new CleanStat dashboard, and includes the violator’s name or business, number of citations, date of most recent citation, and amount paid in fines. Residents can report violations to the city to help to keep their neighbors and local businesses accountable.
Transparency is a buzzword among local governments these days. Baltimore has applied the concept beyond the workings of local government and public servants to discourage bad behavior by private citizens too.

Feeding the community to stop food waste

Plastics and materials aren’t the only waste to manage. It’s estimated that 1.3 billion tonnes of food is wasted around the world each year — that’s one third of the food created for human consumption. Breckland Council, GB is addressing the issue locally by installing community refrigerators around the district. Local businesses can deposit food waste that’s past its sell-by date (but not yet expired), and residents can help themselves to the contents of the fridges for free.
Since the project’s inception in 2018, over 14,500 kg of food have been collected and redistributed — instead of ending up in the trash. At the same time, thousands of residents have saved money on food expenses by utilizing the fridges.

Robots step up to deal with dangerous waste

While many of these efforts focus on the citizen-facing end of waste management, local governments are also making improvements in the safety and efficiency of those who manage the waste.
Every year in Austin, TX, the city collects more than 500 tons of mixed waste — trash and organic debris like trees and sediment — from waterways. Some of these items can be recycled, but they’re too dangerous to be sorted by humans so they end up in landfills. This is a major source of greenhouse gas. To help cut down on emissions, Austin partnered with ZenRobotics to use robots to sort debris and divert reusable items from the landfill.

Takeaways

There’s no one-size fits all approach to improving a city’s waste management system.
As it often is with innovation, the first step is to identify and understand the problem. Each locality will likely face a different challenge, with different root causes. For example, is the problem that people don’t have an easy way to discard trash and recycling, or is it that they don't know how?
Once the problem is clear, cities, towns and counties should look at what solutions have worked — and not worked — for other communities, and decide what to try in their own town.

Discussion

To join the discussion, sign up. It's free!

LP

Lindsay Pica

Co-founder at Govlaunch

AUTHOR

Status

In Progress

Related Stories

story cover image

4 months ago

Baltimore publicly shames businesses for illegal dumping violations

Baltimore, MD is holding repeat illegal dumping violators accountable through public shaming. This initiative is a part of the Mayor's broader waste management "Clean It Up!" campaign.

story cover image

a year ago

Pittsburgh, PA goes big on smart garbage cans

The Department of Public Works is using data from smart trash cans to improve efficiency and reduce emissions.

  • Help
  • Blog
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Contact

© 2020 Govlaunch, Inc.